NAMI Book Shelf: Crazy
Pete Earley is an award-winning investigative reporter whose previous books have been about spies, prisons, and the witness protection program. To some degree, this background may have prepared him to write Crazy: A Father’s Search Through America’s Mental Health Madness, but as NAMI consumers, families, and friends know, nothing ever prepares a person for the shock of mental illness.
“I had no idea,” Earley begins.
Diagnosed with bipolar disorder, Earley’s son, Mike, recently out of college, broke into a stranger’s house to take a bubble bath and vandalized the premises. Frustration with an inability to get Mike into treatment—including his son’s periodic refusals to take medication—as well as the legal procedures surrounding mental illness, caused Earley to use his journalism skills to explore the rapid cycling that exists today between hospitals, courthouses, and jails.
The result is a unique book—one of the best—that presents “criminalization of the mentally ill” not as an abstract concept, but as one drawn in vivid, human dimensions, accompanied by objective and pained reflection. The book alternates between his son’s story in Northern Virginia and Miami-Dade County, where he was able to gain unprecedented access to one of the nation’s largest jails and its psychiatric ward, where guards freely admit to beating patients because, said one, “They’re criminals first, mentally ill second.”
Earley follows the lives of individual consumers, and talks with them and their families, both inside and outside the jail.
At one point, he interviews the parents of Robbie Sherman, a former Boy Scout, whom police had shot and killed during a manic episode. Robbie’s mother showed him a photograph of her son in a 5”x7” frame. “I loved my son. Why did this have to happen,” she cried. “Why did they have to shoot him? Why wouldn’t anyone listen to me when I told them he was sick?”
“I looked at the photograph of Robbie in the gold frame,” Earley writes. “The teenager smiling at me could have been anyone’s son…He could have been Mike.” Indeed, that is one of two key points Earley hopes to make with the book to educate the public: that mental illness can and does strike anyone.
Earley’s other point is that jails have not only become our “new asylums,” but in fact are becoming “institutionalized” as part of a “continuum of care.” No metaphor seems terrible enough to convey what that means. Consumers who run afoul of the law may face an endless maze of cruel choices or dead ends. They may be sent to state or county psychiatric facilities to be “made competent,” with minimal treatment, to stand trial. By the time they are shuttled back to jail and appear in court, they may have de-compensated to a state of incompetence again and therefore be sent back for more “treatment.” Treatment in jail may occur in name only. From both hospitals and jails, there often is little, if any, realistic discharge planning, and the community services which discharged consumers need too often are inadequate or non-existent.
Other obstacles to recovery exist, even when a consumer is relatively lucky.
In the case of Earley’s son, the owner of the house he broke into initially insisted that Mike plead guilty to a felony—which would have ruined any chance he might have had for getting a professional license to pursue his career. Even after being convicted only of a misdemeanor, Mike loses a job because his employer discovers that he is on probation. Never mind the fact that he had disclosed the conviction on his job application.
A principal focus in Earley’s discussion is the tension between the consumer’s right to treatment, the right to refuse treatment, and the frustration of family members or mental health professionals who want to insist on treatment.
Introducing Earley to Freddie Gilbert, one of the consumers whose cases he decides to follow, a doctor observes: “He’s been in this jail before and we know he responds well to medication. The last time he was here, we got him into treatment and he thanked us later…But now the law is forcing us to stand back and do nothing while he continues to get worse. If this man’s arm was fractured, we’d be accused of negligence and cruelty if we didn’t help him. But because he’s mentally ill, we’re not supposed to interfere until he asks.”
Read the first chapter of Crazy at: www.peteearley.com.
Comments about the book also can be posted on the Web site, which Earley personally reads, even though he may not be able to respond to every message.
Earley also investigates the fate of Deidra Sanbourne, whose class action lawsuit against the State of Florida caused her to be released from a state hospital after 20 years, and uncovers “an ugly truth.” After being warehoused for 20 years in a state hospital, Sanbourne ended up warehoused in a squalid boarding home, where her condition only worsened, until her death. It is that truth to which the book speaks.
Purchase Crazy now through this link to Amazon.com and NAMI will receive a portion of the purchase price.